The Boot Index
Trade guide

Roofing Boots: Match the Roof and the Job

Start with the roof, not the boot. Shingles, metal and plastic-sheet roofs each need their own check. We compare two Thorogood wedge boots, but neither maker page claims grip on a roof.

Check the roof material Compare the two boots
Roofer kneeling on a pitched roof nailing architectural asphalt shingles over underlayment

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Amazon links on this page may earn the site a commission. How this works.

Roof type

Match the boot to the roof first

Ask the contractor what the roof needs before you shop.

Each kind of roof needs its own check. Neither boot on this page is proven for any roof.

  • Asphalt shingles Ask about pads

    One roofing boot maker sells swap-out pads for shingle work. The two boots here use a wedge sole instead.

  • Steel or other metal Know the metal

    That same maker says its metal-roof boots are for steel only. Do not stretch that to aluminum or copper.

  • TPO or PVC (plastic sheet) Can be slippery

    Roof maker GAF warns its TPO and PVC sheets may be slippery when wet. Ask what footwear the roof maker allows.

  • Falls Not fall protection

    OSHA has separate fall rules for roofs. Buying a boot does not meet them.

Before you shop:

Ask the contractor which sole or grip system the roof needs. Then follow the job's plan for working up there.

Show where this comes from

Identify the installed roof system, the surface you will actually stand on, and the work procedure before choosing footwear. Shingles, exposed decking and a finished metal panel are separate conditions. None of the affiliate options below is established here as suitable for a particular roof.

Roofing footwear: what to verify before comparing boots
Roof surfaceSource boundaryYour next check
Asphalt shingles Cougar Paws offers a replaceable pad system for shingle and asphalt work. This is a different system from the Thorogood wedge outsole. Ask the contractor whether a specialist system is required. Read the manufacturer's surface guide and current instructions for the exact boot and pad.
Steel or another metal Cougar Paws' FAQ limits its SteelWalker systems to steel and advises against its Performer and Estimator pad boots on steel. Identify the metal and coating. Do not extend a steel-only claim to aluminum, copper or every metal roof. The two wedge boots below have no documented metal-roof claim.
TPO or PVC membrane GAF warns that its EverGuard TPO and PVC membranes may be slippery when wet. Its system manual (PDF, safety considerations) supplies the product-specific context. Get the roof maker's footwear, access and traffic-protection requirements for the installed system. No membrane compatibility or damage-prevention claim is established for either boot below.

These manufacturer references are research links, not affiliate recommendations. Material guidance checked . The Boot Index does not conduct roof-traction or wear tests.

OSHA's construction fall-protection standard addresses roof strength and fall protection, including separate low-slope and steep-roof provisions. A boot purchase does not satisfy those requirements. Cougar Paws also states in its product notice that its footwear is not a fall-protection device. Follow the contractor's plan and manufacturer instructions; a shopping guide cannot clear a roof for access.

Compare the two boots

Both are Thorogood boots with the same wedge sole. The big difference is the safety toe. Neither maker page says the boot is made for roofs.

Swipe sideways to see all 2 boots.

Compare the two boots
Safety toe Thorogood Heritage 6" Safety Toe No safety toe Thorogood Heritage 6" Moc Toe
Good for Jobs that need a safety toe, once the contractor approves the boot for the roof.Jobs with no safety-toe rule, once the contractor approves the boot for the roof.
Safety toe Yes, steel No
Waterproof No No
Shock protection Yes (EH) Yes (EH)
Widths Regular (D) and wide (EE)Regular (D) and wide (EE)
Height 6 inches6 inches
Sole Wedge sole the maker calls slip-resistantWedge sole the maker calls slip-resistant
Roof claim None from the makerNone from the maker
Pros
  • Steel safety toe
  • Same wedge sole as the moc toe
  • Comes in wide
  • Same wedge sole as the safety-toe boot
  • Comes in wide, sizes 6 to 15
Watch out
  • Not waterproof
  • No roof claim from the maker
  • No safety toe
  • Not waterproof
Buy View on Amazon Thorogood specs, checked View on Amazon Thorogood specs, checked
How we picked

We did not test these boots. Here is how we chose them.

What the maker says
Facts from Thorogood's own website, with the date we checked.
Roof and safety rules
Advice from roof makers and OSHA, with a link. These are not boot tests.
Our take
Which jobs each boot fits, based on those facts.
The boots

The two wedge boots

Same sole, different toe. Neither one is sold as a roofing boot.

Safety toe · wedge sole

Thorogood American Heritage 6" Safety Toe MAXWear Wedge

Good for: Jobs that need a safety toe, once the contractor approves the boot for the roof.

Toe
Steel safety toe
Waterproof
No
Height
6 inches
Shock protection
Yes (EH)
Widths
Regular and wide, sizes 7 to 15
Sole
Wedge, called slip-resistant
Build
Stitched (Goodyear storm welt)
Roof claim
None
Why it's here
  • Steel safety toe
  • Same wedge sole as the moc toe
Watch for
  • Not waterproof
  • No roof claim from the maker
See full specs and sources

Documented specification: Style 804-4135 is a 6-inch boot with a steel safety toe and the same MAXWear Wedge slip-resistant outsole as the soft-toe option below. Thorogood documents a composite shank, a removable Ultimate Shock Absorption footbed, a Poron comfort cushion insole, Crazy Horse full-grain American leather, and Goodyear storm welt construction. It cites ASTM F2413-18 for the safety toe and ASTM F2413-18 or ASTM F2892-18 for electrical hazard. The page describes it as non-waterproof. D and EE widths are shown in sizes 7 through 15.

Editorial inference: This is the steel-toe option to check against an employer's footwear rule. That toe claim does not resolve the roof-surface decision. Compare the exact material, footbed, and fit records rather than treating the boots as toe-only variants. Thorogood does not call either one a roofing boot or promise traction on shingles.

Before you buy

Thorogood specifications
Checked

View on Amazon
No safety toe · wedge sole

Thorogood American Heritage 6" Moc Toe

Good for: Jobs with no safety-toe rule, once the contractor approves the boot for the roof.

Toe
No safety toe
Waterproof
No
Height
6 inches
Shock protection
Yes (EH)
Widths
Regular 5 to 15, wide 6 to 15
Sole
Wedge, called slip-resistant
Build
Stitched (Goodyear storm welt)
Roof claim
None
Why it's here
  • Same wedge sole as the safety-toe boot
  • Comes in regular and wide
Watch for
  • No safety toe
  • Not waterproof
See full specs and sources

Documented specification: Style 814-4200 has a MAXWear Wedge slip-resistant outsole, composite shank, full-grain American leather, removable footbed, Poron cushion insole, and Goodyear storm welt construction. It is a non-safety moc toe, is not waterproof, and is marked EH. D widths are shown in sizes 5 to 15 and EE widths in sizes 6 to 15.

Editorial inference: Compare this option only when a safety toe is not required and the contractor accepts its other specifications for the task. Its documented wedge is not evidence of better roof grip than the steel-toe option. Thorogood does not state that it is a roofing boot or guarantee traction on shingles.

Before you buy

Thorogood specifications
Checked

The Amazon listing groups several colors and can open on a different style. Choose Tobacco, style 814-4200, for the boot documented here.

View on Amazon
The sole label

What the sole label tells you

Useful for comparing boots. Not proof of grip on a roof.

Thorogood calls the wedge sole slip-resistant. That helps you compare boots, but it does not show how they grip on a roof.

  • Roof grip No test listed

    Neither maker page gives a grip test on shingles, metal or plastic sheet.

  • Safety toe Only one has it

    Only style 804-4135 has a steel toe. The moc toe, style 814-4200, has none.

  • Same sole Not the same boot

    The leather and insoles differ. Check each boot on its own.

  • Lower-cost boots None here

    No lower-cost boot in our records makes a roof claim, so this page lists none.

Toe rule first:

Ask which safety marking your job needs, then check it on the exact size and version you buy. Our toe comparison explains why toe material alone is not enough.

Show where this comes from

Both Thorogood records name a MAXWear Wedge slip-resistant outsole. That is useful for comparing construction, but it does not establish grip on a roof, resistance to marking its finish, or a safe working pitch. Neither record supplies a roof-surface traction test, and the safety-toe record lists slip and oil resistance without naming a slip-resistance standard.

No budget product in the current source registry has a roof-specific traction claim. The dry-duty Tank is therefore not a recommendation on this page.

Style 804-4135 has a steel safety toe; style 814-4200 does not. Start with the employer's required finished-boot marking, then compare the exact size and variant. A shared outsole does not make the two boots interchangeable.

Before you buy

Check the pair you have first

A new pair helps only if it fixes a real gap.

Full fit checklist

Buy a new pair only if it fixes something your job needs. Do these three checks on the ground.

  • Step 1 Name the gap

    Write down the roof type, the sole the job allows and the safety marking you need. If you do not know, ask first.

  • Step 2 Check your pair

    Match the model and marking. Look at the soles for wear, damage or dirt, using the maker's care advice.

  • Step 3 Fit on the ground

    Try new boots on level ground with your work socks, while you can still return them.

Never on the roof:

Do not break in or test new boots during roof work.

Show the full checklist

A new pair is useful only if it closes a specific requirement or fit gap. Bring the exact model and its manufacturer instructions to the person responsible for footwear selection. Use this checklist on the ground; it is not a roof-access test.

  1. Write down the missing requirement. Record the roof material, accepted outsole or traction system, required toe marking and any exposure requirement. An unknown is a reason to confirm the requirement before shopping.
  2. Check the actual pair and variant. Match the model and marking, and inspect its condition using the maker's care instructions. Ask about damaged, worn or contaminated soles. A catalog description cannot establish the condition of a used pair.
  3. Try the fit while a return remains possible. Use the work-boot fit checklist with your work socks and permitted inserts. Check both feet and the closure on level ground. Do not use roof work to break in or test a new boot.

If the existing pair meets the confirmed requirements and remains serviceable, this page supplies no reason by itself to replace it. If your actual task is on a cured slab, use the dry-concrete guide instead of treating a roofing shortlist as a general work-boot ranking.

What the maker pages do not say

Here is what Thorogood's pages leave out, as of September 30, 2026:

  • Neither page calls the boot a roofing boot or gives a grip test on any roof.
  • Neither page names the slip test behind the word "slip-resistant."
  • Neither boot is waterproof, and neither has insulation.
  • The Amazon listing for the moc toe groups several colors. Choose Tobacco, style 814-4200.

The Boot Index does not run roof-grip or wear tests. We recheck every boot's maker page at least every 90 days.

Read how we pick boots, the slip-resistant guide and how to break in new boots.

Common questions

What kind of boots do roofers wear?

It depends on the roof and the job. The contractor's plan, the roof type, how steep it is and the fall-protection plan decide. A wedge sole or a slip-resistant label does not prove grip on shingles.

Are heavy work boots good for roofing?

Weight alone does not decide it. The safety toe your job needs, a secure fit, the roof type and the contractor's rules all matter. Check the exact boot, not general claims about lug, wedge or flexible soles.

Guide updated . Manufacturer verification dates are shown beside the product sources.

Compare boots for your job

Guides by trade, surface, safety spec, and fit. Product specifications are traced to dated manufacturer records.

Browse the index